Convergence
- JamesD
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 11
- Thank you received: 0
15 years 5 months ago #3686
by JamesD
Convergence was created by JamesD
Hi,
I'm having troubles with convergence. I'm fairly new to FEA so its difficult to trust my results. I understand the concept of convergence but I'm not entirely sure what qualifies as a converged result.
I have a model that I have meshed with a second order Netgen 3D mesh. I have re-entrant corners but these are not showing any signs of singularities to start off with.
If I have my mesh set to moderate and I start to decrease my element size I start to converge towards an answer with reasonable results but when the mesh gets too fine I start to get higher stresses again, not in the corners but just off to the side of them. If I run the mesh at coarse I get similar results but if I run it at Fine or Very Fine I get the offset corner stresses.
I am unable to fillet the corners due to restrictions in the model. I have tried to model this as a plastic material but made no difference (probably did it wrong).
So what my question is, is if I start to converge towards a reasonable answer using a moderate mesh by decreasing elements size can I say that the result has converged or do I have to eliminate any chance of singularities before I can assume anything? And should the result converge to the same answer whether a coarse...very fine mesh is chosen or not or is element size alone good enough?
Any suggestions would be great!
James
I'm having troubles with convergence. I'm fairly new to FEA so its difficult to trust my results. I understand the concept of convergence but I'm not entirely sure what qualifies as a converged result.
I have a model that I have meshed with a second order Netgen 3D mesh. I have re-entrant corners but these are not showing any signs of singularities to start off with.
If I have my mesh set to moderate and I start to decrease my element size I start to converge towards an answer with reasonable results but when the mesh gets too fine I start to get higher stresses again, not in the corners but just off to the side of them. If I run the mesh at coarse I get similar results but if I run it at Fine or Very Fine I get the offset corner stresses.
I am unable to fillet the corners due to restrictions in the model. I have tried to model this as a plastic material but made no difference (probably did it wrong).
So what my question is, is if I start to converge towards a reasonable answer using a moderate mesh by decreasing elements size can I say that the result has converged or do I have to eliminate any chance of singularities before I can assume anything? And should the result converge to the same answer whether a coarse...very fine mesh is chosen or not or is element size alone good enough?
Any suggestions would be great!
James
Moderators: catux
Time to create page: 0.113 seconds